Finger vs. Stylus vs. Thumboard (Part 2)

Next we’ll look at the stylus oriented interface. This type of interface has been around since the 20th Century. Heck people have been using stylus-like tools to document things for thousands of years. Let’s see what the pros and cons for this one are:

Stylus oriented interface:

Pros:

– Stylus has a much smaller surface area than a finger

– Buttons can be smaller since the input device is smaller. This will allow you to fit more visible commands on a smaller screen without having to navigate multiple views.

– More editable information can be displayed at one time

– No finger smudges on the screen

– Stylus makes handwriting recognition easy to implement on a small screen.

– The device can be smaller and have a larger screen since it doesn’t need room for hardware buttons

– No moving parts to wear out

Cons:

– Smaller buttons means you have to be more accurate with the stylus

– You have to pull the stylus out of the side of the device when you want to interact with it.

– Stylus can be easily dropped or lost

– You have to look at the screen to navigate the device (Not safe to be used while driving, running, bicycling, etc.)

– Requires two hands; one to hold the device, one to hold the stylus

Can you think of any other pros and cons for this type of interface?

Navigation: Part 1

Originally published on Pocketnow on June 20, 2007. More Thought articles from the Pocketnow archive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *